Showing posts with label Russia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Russia. Show all posts

Friday, July 29, 2016

Promises Made Should Not Be So Easily Forgotten.

"There is no act of treachery or meanness of which a political party is not capable; for in politics there is no honor.  Benjamin Disraeli.

It was not long ago the shining stars of the republican party were a group of midwestern men running for governor of Wisconsin, Michigan and Ohio, Most of their campaign was built around the promise of eviscerating the collective bargaining agreements. It seemed odd that these men who all called themselves "compassionate conservatives," or something similar, made this the central tenet of their candidacy. 

Despite their claims of fiscal responsibility they were going to tell all of these people that despite agreements, signed intractably by elected officials they were no longer going to honor these promises. It had become inconvenient. Somehow these men could justify reneging on legally binding contracts. And they were elected. It was illuminating.

Donald Trump, the republican candidate for president, has stated that he may not be inclined to defend the Baltic states against a Russian invasion. Despite the fact they are NATO members. His followers love the bluster. They adore his claims of demanding member nations toe the line, or be left behind.

NATO was formed with one mission, to control the wars that had been consuming Europe for hundreds of years. And consumed the world for the previous fifty. It was not a marketing tool, or an economic forum. It was built around Article 5. An attack against any NATO ally is an attack against all NATO allies. It is as simple as that. 13 words sums up the whole game.

Germany has vowed to defend the Baltic states in case of invasion. It does not take a particularly vivid imagination to see bad things arising from Germany and Russia locked in a land war in the Balkans. It does not really take any imagination at all. Just an internet connection or a library. It has happened more than once, and it never ended well.
During the course of WWII it is conservatively estimated forty five million civilians were killed. It will be worse in the next superpower struggle. If Germany and Russia become entangled in a protracted struggle it will only be a matter of time before the whole region is in flames, and there goes the whole thing all over again. So, if a person is inclined to ask "what possible effect could the fall of Estonia have on my life?" It is probably a lot better if that question is never answered.

Thursday, January 14, 2016

How Can The Threat Be Ended?

Russia has made some marginal gains, at a huge expense in Syria. With the might of Russian bombs the forces of Assad have made inroads into areas around Allepo, but nothing that would offer much hope for the regime. And Putin has been quoted as saying "we are far from using everything we are capable of."

American airstrikes in Iran and Syria continue to kill suspected terrorists. And they have, it seems, no plan to slow the sorties. "If you are part of ISIL we will kill you." that is their mission statement right now.

Millions of dollars worth of bombs are being dropped. Buildings and people are exploding at an alarming rate. Death has come to the Middle East, and he is flying a billion dollar, multi purpose fighter/bomber.

But, repeated estimates of "enemy combatants" hover around 30,000 insurgent fighters. Despite the
fact that American estimates are between 23,000 and 25,000 ISIL members killed. Russian and Syrian estimates of casualties are similar. And that number is supposedly adjusted to exclude the civilian casualties.

Even if one assumes that the estimates of combatants killed are overestimated ISIS is replenishing ranks with alarming efficiency. And sooner or later enough lives will be lost and money spent that the super powers will take their expensive equipment and go home. What then?

One thing neither of the great powers is talking about, and it seems like it should have been the first step, is "what should we do to keep a person who is neutral from joining the ranks of ISIL?"  They didn't ask before entering the fray, and they haven't asked since.

How can this river of willing soldiers be stopped? What steps need to be taken to end the enlistment?

It is a stretch to say America or Russia can understand the workings of the Middle Eastern mind, but if they ever want to leave with dignity and hope of security they had better find out.